On the sixth day of my NY vacation, I was walking around Brooklyn in the bitter, biting cold while a scant amount of snow fell about me. I was buttoned up in my warm pink coat, but my gloves were back at "home," so my hands were stiff with cold. My face was frozen too. Clearly I needed a nice shelter from all this winter, as well as a good lunch (my stomach was grumbling loudly). I made myself walk a little bit longer, and finally I found something: Original Mexican Taqueria. I always enjoy a good hearty Mexican meal at any time of day, so I decided to stop there to eat and rest before proceeding on my way. I was hungry enough for anything, so I shook my umbrella free of residual snow and walked inside.
I seated myself at a table and studied the vast menu. There were tons of choices: burritos, tacos, tostadas, quesadillas, and so on. After looking at the menu for a long time, I finally decided on a Vegetarian Burrito (I usually don't eat meat at lunchtime), with some tortilla chips and pico de gallo for an appetizer. I told the cooks what I wanted (there was no waitstaff), then sat back down and looked carefully around me. The atmosphere was a bit boring; nothing was really happening. There was no cheerful chatter, no big hordes of hungry people occupying the tables. It was quiet, and most of the tables were empty. I found it rather dull.
My food came promptly; certainly not as fast as Teotihuacan, but there wasn't a super long wait. My burrito was stuffed with many things; black beans, rice, salsa, guacamole, sour cream, and lettuce. The beans were very toothsome and well cooked, but there were so many in my burrito that it overpowered the other additions. The rice was also expertly prepared, with a nicely mild, yet distinct flavor. The salsa, guacamole, and sour cream tasted average, and the lettuce was a bit limp. All these fillings were embedded on a flour tortilla, which tasted like a flour tortilla should taste. The tortilla chips were freshly fried. Although they were a bit tough and hard to chew, they tasted just fine when a little heap of fresh pico was sitting upon the point. The pico was a little bland (they didn't use the best tomatoes), but it tasted fresh and the cilantro flavor was strong. It was a normal, pleasant meal, but it wasn't at all up to par with Felipe's back home.
When I got my burrito and chips, the cooks didn't provide me with a knife or fork. Just a burrito on a plate. I tried to eat it with my hands, but the tortilla split and some of the fillings spilled out. I had to go up and ask for a knife and fork; you would think that the cooks would have the courtesy to give them to you without you having to ask. It was kind of embarrassing. So the service at Original Mexican Taqueria was not the best. They were forgetful and didn't take good care of me. The food gets a B+, while the service gets a C. Felipe's is worlds better.
Original Mexican Taqueria is a place, in my opinion, where people who don't care about really good food should go. So if you want good Mexican in NY, try another spot. In a pinch, though, you can dine there, if you have nowhere else to go. "Another Vegetarian Burrito, Miss?" I'll pass.
